Friday, 13 September 2013

The Universal Definition of Family and the Inequalities it brings


A question that was brought to my attention in my CHYS 3P38 class was why we need to define what a family is.

It got me thinking. Why do we need to have a definition of a family? What does having a definition of family really do?

After looking over several definitions of a family, specifically William N. Stephens (1963) definition it has come to my attention that by defining what a family is, we are suggesting that there are certain social groups that do not count as a family (although they might actually be one).  Also, the definition seems to portray the adults in the family have the most power and leaves the children’s role in a family out.

In the 21st century these inequitable definitions do not work. A family, now a day’s consist of more than a father, mother and their children.  There are many different types of families (mixed families, single parent families, families with no children, common law families, adopted families, ect.) and as one grows up they will continually be adding to the people that they consider family (when a child gets married, or starts a relationship with someone, when a person has children of their own or adopts a child, etc.).

Another inequality that the universal definition of families brings up is that the children always seem to be on the receiving end of all the lessons a family has to offer. This is not the case though. Yes, children do learn a lot of life skills from their family, but they also offer a lot of learning opportunities for their family. So, the child is not the only person that grows in a family, rather families learn and mature together as a unit.

 
Personally I grew up in a nuclear family, which consists of my dad, mom, two brothers and me. The definition of a family would suggest that my parents, my brother and I are a perfect example of what a family is. I would argue though that this is not the case. Just because my family fits into the universal definition of a family, does not mean that everyone’s family is structured the exact same way. There are many different structures of families and they are usually not as clear cut as the nuclear family seems to be.
 

On top of the fact that there are many different types of families other than the type that I have, I would also like to point out that my parents and my brothers, are not the only people that I consider family. There are many people that have come into my life that I now consider to be family. So, maybe family is not even something that can be set in stone by a definition because it can be adapted over time.
 

With all this being said, it seems as though the universal definition of families causes more problems than anything. The universal definition of family describes a nuclear family (with a father, mother and their children), but is not an acceptable definition for describing all the other types of families that are in the world. With the universal definition as it is, society is setting up family structures to be an unequal part of everyday life because not everyone fits into the category of a nuclear family. The definition also does not consider every persons role in a family, which creates inequalities between adults and children in a family.
Due to all the problems the universal definition of a family brings up, it could be asked if we actually need to define a family because in reality everyone in the world has different family experiences and should be able to describe this social group as what their family actually is. This way no structure or person is left out of being in or an important part of a family because of what society believes a family should be.
 

 

2 comments:

  1. Hey Katie!

    Great points brought up in the article. Like yourself, I have many people who aren't in my immediate family that I consider to be my family. For example, my dance family- a group of teammates and my teachers that have been a part of my life for as long as I can remember. And then there are my friends who I consider to be my family.

    However according to the definition these people really aren't part of my 'family'. Everyone has different beliefs as to what counts as family. This just fields the complexity of creating a universal definition.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great ideas for what and who can be considered a family.

    ReplyDelete